Thursday, October 31, 2019

Commission denies herniated disc occupational disease claim from working only 17 days

Jerry Sample v Drivers Management LLC, Werner Enterprises 
Ace American Insurance

Release Date:  Oct. 30, 2019 (Accident date Jan 2, 2019)

Venue:  Callaway County

Length: 16 pages

Plot Summary:  The Commission affirms a denial of benefits in a hardship hearing for an alleged injury by occupational disease from performing deliveries over the Christmas season which included neck pain and electrical sensations in both arms.  A defense expert concluded claimant's employment for 17 days  was not the prevailing factor in  large C5-6 spinal cord compression and degenerative changes at other levels.  


https://labor.mo.gov/sites/labor/files/decisions_wc/SampleJerry17-00670910-30-19.pdf

Inj.  No.  17-006709


Cast:
Farmer, ALJ
Kelley, atty
Haeckel, atty
Lee
Fan
Orr
Moore
Cantrell
Chabot


Comments:

Claimant's expert, Dr. Lee, found the disc herniation flowed from claimant's strenuous activity in the absence of any other event to explain what claimant described as an acute, gradual onset of symptoms.  ALJ Farmer found claimant already had pre-existing degenerative changes which were not worsened or changed by the work activities. The history of gradual, non-specific onset of symptoms was consistent with a chronic condition.