Friday, February 10, 2017
Inability to explain how an accident occurred did not preclude an award of benefits
Phillips v ConAgra
2017 MOWCLR Lexis 15
Feb. 7, 2017
The Commission affirmed a finding that claimant's accident arose out of an in the course of employment.
Claimant fell off of a ramp while going into a break room and broke his hip. He filed a claim that he slipped and fell but his medical records fail to identify a cause for his injury and that he did not identify why he fell.
The commission deferred to the ALJ's finding of credibility that claimant had an accident. Claimant identified an occupational hazard of walking on "a three to five-inch graded ramp without a guard rail while wearing steel-toed shoes in order to access a designated break area. We find that employer's unguarded ramp constituted a risk source not encountered in employee's everyday life" despite inconsistencies in his medical history and earlier versions that he could not explain why he fell. Claimant was entitled to benefits despite an "inability to explain why an accident occurred".
The employer offered no expert opinion to identify idiopathic medical conditions caused claimant to fall at the time.
The Commission affirmed an award of 22.5% for a hip fracture and denied a motion for costs.