Friday, October 26, 2018

PTD against fund based on primary injury of lumbar strain

Hillyard v American Staffing
2018 MO WCLR LEXIS 233
Inj.  No.  12-030075
Oct. 10, 2018

The Commission affirms a 2-1 award of permanent total against the second injury fund. 

The defense relied upon expert opinion that claimant sustained a lumbar strain in the primary injury superimposed on severe back pain for years and a dissent found the claimant lacked credibility to establish he was unable to maintain gainful employment.

The 63-year old claimant alleges he twisted his back while moving boxes.  He declined a prior recommendation for back surgery.   Claimant relies upon opinion of Dr. Volarich that he aggravated prior spinal conditions.  The ALJ found claimant sustained 15% disability on the basis of a strain. 


ALJ: Teer
Atty: Cox, Ahrenbach
Experts:  Volarich, Lalk, Cantrell