Thursday, April 1, 2021

Claimant fails to prove accident that he hit his head on a truck and caused brain damage

Mark Hundley v Conagra

Release Date:  3/31/2021  (Accident date:  2014)

Venue:  Boone County

Plot Summary:  Commission affirms a denial of a claim based on a defense of failure to prove accident when claimant alleges he hit his head when he was a restrained driver wearing a hard hat and his seat suddenly moved forward causing him to his his head.  

A defense expert contends there was no evidence he sustained a head injury and complaints  of unsteadiness more likely could be attributed to non-traumatic diabetic neuropathy and left visual defect was more likely due to diabetic condition than a brain injury. Claimant's expert based opinions on a flawed medical history that the hard hat was shattered.  

A dissent felt claimant established an accident but failed to prove injury by accident due to equivocal medical opinion about the cause of any traumatic brain injury. 


14-094684 

Cast

Young, ALJ 

Netemeyer, atty

Neumeyer, atty

Shoemaker

Shah

Silverman

Peeples